myths about onions and eye damage


Reading Time: < 1 minute

myths about onions and eye damage

Onions and tears – are they linked? Let’s explore this age-old culinary mystery and debunk the myths.

When an onion is sliced, it releases a compound called syn-propanethial-S-oxide. This reacts with the moisture in our eyes, creating sulfuric acid. Our body’s natural defense mechanism then kicks in – producing tears to protect us.

So, it’s not the onion’s fault!

But, don’t worry – there are ways to minimize tearing while prepping onions. Chilling the onion beforehand helps slow down the chemical reaction. Or, you can try wearing goggles or using a sharp knife.

Myth #1: Onions cause eye damage

To address the myth that onions cause eye damage, dive into the section exploring Myth #1: Onions cause eye damage. Gain clarity by exploring the sub-sections: Explanation of the myth, Dispelling the myth with facts and scientific evidence.

Explanation of the myth

Onions get blamed for eye damage, but it’s just a myth. Compounds, known as amino acid sulfoxides, react with enzymes when cut or crushed, making volatile gases. These gases turn into sulfuric acid, irritating the eyes and causing tears. So, it’s not the onion that’s harmful, but the chemical reaction when it meets air.

To understand why onions have this effect, we need to look at science. Onions contain cysteine sulfoxides, which give off a pungent odor and taste. When an onion is cut, the compounds mix with enzymes in onion cells, creating sulfenic acids. These then make volatile gases, which make our eyes tear up.

Everyone doesn’t experience eye irritation when cutting onions. Some people have higher tolerance of these gases, while others may be more sensitive due to genetics or prior exposure. To minimize eye irritation when preparing onions, chill them or use a sharp knife, which reduces cell damage and limits gas production.

Dispelling the myth with facts and scientific evidence

Onions have been wrongly blamed for eye damage. But, research has proven this claim to be false. The syn-propanethial-S-oxide (SPO) compound is released when onions are cut. It causes tears, but no harm to eyes.

The tears from SPO are beneficial, as they wash away any irritants. To reduce eye irritation when cutting onions, chill the onion in the freezer for 10-15 minutes. Cutting onions under running water or in front of a fan is also helpful.

Goggles or onion-cutting glasses can be worn too. This creates a physical barrier, stopping any tear production and discomfort.

Myth #2: Cutting onions underwater prevents tears

To eliminate the myth that cutting onions underwater prevents tears, dive into a detailed analysis of this claim. First, we’ll examine the myth itself and its purported benefits. Then, we’ll unravel the reasons why this method fails to deliver on its promise of tear-free onion cutting.

Explanation of the myth

The myth that onions can be cut underwater to avoid tears has been passed down for generations. Nevertheless, this has no scientific proof: onions release syn-propanethial-S-oxide when cut, and the chemical is water-soluble. Chopping in water may even make the situation worse – creating more fumes in a small space.

No evidence supports cutting onions underwater to reduce tears. The chemical can travel through air or water. Besides, it can be unsafe – sharp knives and wet surfaces are a risky combination.

To prevent tears, chill onions before cutting them. This reduces irritant release. Or, put on goggles or glasses. They’ll form a barrier between eyes and the irritating chemicals.

Explanation of why this method doesn’t work

Submerging onions underwater may seem like a good idea to stop watery eyes. But, it doesn’t work. Onions contain sulfur compounds that cause tears. They react with moisture in our eyes, creating a sulfuric acid. This irritates tear ducts, making us cry.

Underwater cutting can reduce the gas released. But, it doesn’t eliminate it. So, your eyes will still sting. Plus, it’s potentially dangerous. Working with knives underwater can lead to accidents or injuries. It’s best to use kitchen tools on dry surfaces. Safety first!

Myth #3: Cooking onions eliminates eye irritation

To address the myth that cooking onions eliminates eye irritation, let’s delve into the reality behind this claim. We’ll examine the explanation of the myth and why cooking fails to completely eliminate eye irritation. By understanding these sub-sections, you’ll gain clarity on the true effects of cooking onions and how it relates to the often-misunderstood notion of reducing eye irritation.

Explanation of the myth

Cooking onions doesn’t fix eye irritation. The myth suggests that this cooking task reduces irritants, but it’s wrong. Cutting onions combines enzymes and amino acids to create a smelly gas known as syn-Propanethial-S-oxide. This gas causes stinging eyes and tears. Cooking onions may soften the smell, but it doesn’t stop the gases from bothering our eyes.

We have to understand the science to prevent disappointment. Chilling or goggles won’t help. Why does this myth live on? Maybe we hope there’s an easy fix for the discomfort.

We can’t avoid eye irritation, but we can reduce it. Get proper ventilation in the kitchen. This will lower the concentration of the gas. Also, cut onions in running water or use a damp paper towel next to the cutting board to absorb some of the gas before it gets in your eyes.

Explanation of why cooking doesn’t completely eliminate eye irritation

Cooking onions might help with eye irritation. Yet, it doesn’t make it go away completely. Even though heat can break down the compounds that cause tears and discomfort, some of them still escape into the air and reach your eyes. They are called sulfenic acids.

Another factor to consider is the time of cooking. The longer you cook onions, the fewer irritating compounds stay in the air. But if you just briefly sauté them, there may still be enough to cause your eyes to bother you.

Red onions have more sulfenic acids than white or yellow onions. So cooking red onions might not work as well when trying to avoid eye irritation.

Pro Tip: Before cutting onions, put them in the refrigerator. This minimizes the irritants released into the air while you chop them.

Conclusion: Debunking the myths about onions and eye damage

Onions and tears have gone hand-in-hand for a while. Many myths suggest that onions can cause damage to our eyes. But, these claims are not true. When onions are cut or chopped, they give off syn-propanethial-S-oxide, which can be irritating. But, this is only temporary and not harmful.

The idea that cutting onions underwater or wearing goggles can stop the irritation has no evidence to back it up. The best way to reduce the effects is to make sure there’s proper ventilation in the kitchen. Open the windows or turn on an exhaust fan. That’ll spread out the volatile compounds and make them less irritating.

People differ in their sensitivity to onion-induced tears. Some may experience discomfort, while others don’t. It depends on the individual’s tear-production and how much they can tolerate.

Don’t fear the onion! Instead, enjoy the culinary journey with confidence. Remember, the tears are just a passing inconvenience, not a cause for alarm. So, cut that onion and savor the flavor!

Frequently Asked Questions

FAQs about Myths about Onions and Eye Damage:

1. Can cutting onions really damage your eyes?

No, cutting onions does not cause permanent damage to your eyes. It may cause temporary irritation, but the effects are not long-lasting.

2. Why does cutting onions make your eyes water?

When you cut onions, they release a gas called syn-propanethial-S-oxide, which irritates the eyes and triggers tear production as a protective mechanism.

3. Does refrigerating onions prevent eye irritation?

No, refrigerating onions does not prevent eye irritation. The gas released by onions cannot be contained or neutralized by chilling them.

4. Can wearing goggles or glasses help prevent onion-induced eye irritation?

Yes, wearing goggles or glasses can create a barrier between your eyes and the onion’s gas, reducing the amount of irritants reaching your eyes.

5. Are sweet onions less likely to cause eye irritation?

No, the variety of onion (sweet or otherwise) does not impact the release of eye-irritating gas. All onions contain the same compounds that cause tear production.

6. Does cutting onions under running water prevent eye irritation?

No, cutting onions under running water does not prevent eye irritation. The gas released by onions is volatile and cannot be washed away.

Leave a Comment